Why this result
David and Lisa's $180,000 salary already fills the 10–22% brackets every year, so the structure's interest income is taxed at 22–24% and the recognized gain stacks on a higher base. Total federal tax therefore runs higher than a cash sale. They do keep more actual cash — the interest is real income — but the present-value advantage is razor-thin and hinges on the discount rate: a still-earning couple who could reinvest lump-sum proceeds might do as well selling outright. The $180,000 of unrecaptured §1250 gain is recognized first under the installment method, front-loaded into the first two years at up to 25%.
Key assumptions
- Filing status
- Married filing jointly
- State income tax
- None (Nevada)
- Gross-profit ratio
- 70.625%
- Structure
- $1,400,000 over 10 years at 4.8% (level payment ≈ $179,550/yr)
- Other income
- $180,000 combined salary, ongoing
- Unrecaptured §1250 gain
- $180,000, recognized first in cumulative-gain order
- NIIT threshold
- $250,000 (MFJ)
- §453A interest charge
- None — aggregate obligations under $5,000,000
Structured sale — year by year
Each payment is part return of capital, part recognized gain, part interest.
| Year | Payment | Interest | Gain recognized | Federal tax |
| Closing | $200,000 | $0 | $141,250 | $35,444 |
| 1 | $179,550 | $67,200 | $79,347 | $33,262 |
| 2 | $179,550 | $61,807 | $83,156 | $28,992 |
| 3 | $179,550 | $56,156 | $87,147 | $28,212 |
| 4 | $179,550 | $50,233 | $91,330 | $27,470 |
| 5 | $179,550 | $44,025 | $95,714 | $26,693 |
| 6 | $179,550 | $37,520 | $100,308 | $25,878 |
| 7 | $179,550 | $30,703 | $105,123 | $25,024 |
| 8 | $179,550 | $23,558 | $110,169 | $24,130 |
| 9 | $179,550 | $16,071 | $115,457 | $23,192 |
| 10 | $179,550 | $8,224 | $120,999 | $22,210 |
- The §1250 recapture is concentrated in years 0–1, which is why the early-year tax is higher than a level spread would suggest.